|
Review
Nominated for the Best Picture
Oscar in 1937, this hugely popular Universal film followed the teenage
soprano's star making debut in Three Smart Girls. After the release of this second
vehicle Deanna Durbin's salary was doubled to $3,000 a week plus a
$10,000 bonus for each feature. 100 Men And a Girl is a joy of a film, with
sentiment, comedy, glorious music and a glittering star at its centre.
|
| |
 |
The Oscar nominated script introduces us to John Cardwell (Adolphe
Menjou), an unemployed musician, and his daughter Patricia/Patsy
(Deanna Durbin). One evening he finds a purse containing some money,
which he keeps, and leads Patsy to believe that he has found employment
playing in Leopold Stokowski's orchestra, paying their back
rent with the money from the purse. When Patsy visits the
concert hall where her father is supposed to be playing she
uncovers the deception, confronts her father and resolves to return
the purse to its owner. Patsy finds the owner, Mrs Frost (Alice
Brady) entertaining high society. Patsy wheedles a reward from
Mrs Frost, and with it repays the "missing" money. Patsy
ends up singing for the guests - the lovely A Heart That's
Free - and tells Mrs Frost about her out-of-work
father, and all his similarly unemployed musician friends. The
idea of starting her own orchestra is born, with Mrs Frost sort-of
agreeing to be patron.
Complications arise! Mrs Frost goes "overseas",
Mr Frost (Eugene Pallette) knows nothing about any orchestra and
is not interested. After much teenage angst from Deanna, the whole
idea of the "symphony orchestra of unemployed musicians" has
no hope of coming into being unless they can find a famous, promotable image
to attach to their enterprise. Patsy's eyes widen. "Mr Stokowski!"
|
|
The remainder of the film concerns Patsy's endeavours to
obtain the famed conductor to agree to help, for one night, "one hundred men
and a girl". Problem! The great man is committed to conduct in Europe,
but from the very outset we know how it all will end. This is a 1930s fairytale,
a fairytale that a world recovering from the Great Depression needed and wanted
to hear. Universal's producer, Joe Pasternak, tells the heartwarming,
but never cloying, story with economy - just over eighty minutes - and
uses the best resources the studio had to offer. The original score, which
did win an Oscar, is at times arrestingly lovely. The sets are excellent,
from theatres and plush apartments, to boarding houses and basements. The script
is tight, often very funny, and the lighting and camerawork are excellent.
For its time the sound recording is outstanding - another Oscar nomination.
The climax of the film has the unemployed musicians, having invaded Stokowski's
house, ranged on the stairs of his house, playing Liszt's Hungarian
Rhapsody No.2, Stokowski conducting from the top of the stairs mentally "pushed" on
by Deanna, with the camera excitingly capturing it all. It is exhilarating.
For the second time Deanna Durbin was directed
by Henry Koster. Most commentary insists that the teenager's acting
was "limited" -
but this is not a heavy drama. Under Koster's direction she delivers
a performance that is dramatic enough at times, funny a lot
of the time, charming and - the most surprising thing about Deanna
Durbin - so natural and unaffected. Just look at her entrance on
the stairs as she greets Adolphe Menjou (her first close-up revealing
the slightly straightened dentures), a wonderful
minute or so that she spends sharing a chair with Mischa Auer,
and her agony at Mrs Frost's party when all she wants is food while the
hostess insists that she sing.
Once again Pasternak and/or Koster have Miss Durbin surrounded by
a throng of tried and true professionals. Adolphe Menjou is excellent, charming,
subtle and never maudlin in a father role that could be so corny. Alice Brady,
Eugene Pallette, Mischa Auer (in this he is outstanding) and Billy Gilbert
are always welcome screen faces. Finally there is Frank Jenks as the cab driver
who has a couple of great "bits" as he drives the fareless Deanna
around the city. You probably don't know Frank Jenks by name, but you
will definitely know the face.
The film has loads of beautiful music. Mozart, Tchaikovsky,
Wagner, Verdi and Liszt, all conducted by Stokowski. In addition there
is the delightful It's Raining Sunbeams and the previously mentioned A
Heart That's Free. This movie comes from an era when movie audiences were
regularly treated to music that had endured the test of time, and when the
general population knew the names of great conductors, pianists, dancers and
singers. Sad how today's technology has narrowed the cultural awareness of the "general
public".
No apologies for this film. That 100 Men And
a Girl is almost
seventy years old has no bearing whatsoever. This is a first rate movie from
the past starring one of the loveliest young talents ever projected onto the
silver screen.
|